0

Giving Protective Cover

India must get down to finding a viable health insurance model for the needy

 

India has been described by columnist Martin Wolf as a premature superpower: one of the world’s largest economies, but a country with a low per capita income. In countries with low per capita income, public health expenditure has to be primarily focused on preventive healthcare, especially protection from communicable diseases. Curative care has to be largely financed from private sources. But what is the best way to do that, and how do we provide healthcare to those too poor to pay for themselves?

Health insurance is the most effective way of privately financing healthcare. However, global experience shows that private health insurance systems work in countries with per capita incomes of at least Rs 4.5 to Rs 5 lakh. Clearly, with a per capita income of only around Rs 50,000, India still has a long way to go. But there are large variations around this average and those in higher income groups can well afford to insure themselves while those at the lower end cannot. From the perspective of health insurance, three broad groups are identifiable.

For those in the lowest income groups, the government has launched a bold experiment under an insurance scheme called the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY). Under this scheme which started in 2007, ‘below poverty line’ or BPL families are given an entitlement of up to Rs 30,000 per family per year to cover treatment costs. The insurance premium is paid by the central and state governments in the ratio of 75:25 (higher for some special category states).

To minimise leakage, the scheme has introduced cashless transfers through smart cards. It is still early days. So far, 26 states are participating in the programme, of which 22 have started issuing smart cards. About one crore cards have been issued so far. Bihar, rapidly moving from near-‘failed state’ status to almost a star performer in governance, has just extended the scheme’s coverage from eight to 30 districts in
partnership with four major private insurance agencies through competitive bidding. Rs 30,000 cannot cover the treatment cost of catastrophic illness, but it is not chicken feed in a country where average income is only Rs 50,000 and where BPL families cannot afford any healthcare at all.

Giving Protective Cover - India must get down to finding a viable health insurance model for the needy

 

Since states typically inflate their BPL lists well beyond those identified as BPL by the central authorities, RSBY could eventually cover over 400 million people. If properly implemented, alongside the National Rural Health Mission, it could prove to be as much of a political game changer as NREGA, and set an example for the rest of the developing world.

There is a Distortion in the market for private Health Insurance.. it is interesting to ask why no insurer has yet offered a proper insurance product to beat the competition. is tere a cartel at work.

If RSBY provides minimal insurance cover for a large number of beneficiaries, at the other end of the spectrum we have maximum healthcare cover at a nominal premium for a relatively small group of beneficiaries – government employees, including retirees, and their families – under the Central Government Health Scheme (CGHS). Though the number of beneficiaries is large in absolute terms, it is still a small fraction of the country’s population. Though probably the best among the three broad systems of health insurance found in the country, CGHS still needs major reform.

Though coverage is virtually unlimited in theory, including treatment abroad, what actually gets covered is still subject to discretionary approval by the concerned authorities. That needs to change. The premiums are nominal and need to be enhanced, along with a ‘deductible’ share payable by the beneficiary, subject to a ceiling, to make the system financially viable. Moreover, private hospitals are increasingly reluctant to treat under CGHS coverage. They complain that getting paid is a nightmare. Nevertheless, for the beneficiaries this is on the whole a good insurance scheme.

Between RSBY beneficiaries at the bottom and CGHS beneficiaries at the other end, we have the rest of the population, close to half a billion people, left to their own devices. Those employed in the corporate sector, just a few million people, usually get medical care cover as part of their benefits. Those in high income groups, again just a few million, buy their own insurance from private insurance agencies. The rest pay what they can afford for doctors, medicines and private hospital care, or they queue up in public hospitals.

The rest pay what they can afford for doctors, medicines and private hospital care, or they queue up in public hospitals

 

The challenge is to find a viable health insurance model for them, based on low margins and high volume. There is a peculiar distortion here in the market for private health insurance that needs to be addressed. Health insurance is bought not for treating a flu or sprained ankle but as protection against the huge expenses of treatment for a catastrophic illness or accident.

Elsewhere in the world, a good insurance policy provides unlimited cover for such illness, with a ‘stop loss’ limit beyond which there is no ‘deductible’ payable by the policy-holder. In India, it is the reverse. The ‘stop loss’ limit is a cap beyond which the insurer provides no cover! It is interesting to ask why no private insurer has yet offered a proper health insurance product to beat the competition. Is there perhaps a cartel at work?

Nikesh Sharma

Nikesh Sharma is a health and beauty writer, independent researcher with a long history and expertise of providing reliable and relatable health content for magazines, newsletters, websites including blogs and journals. He also enjoy exploring men’s and women’s health category writing articles about sex and relationships, product review and providing information on sexual health.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Urology Procedures India

Urocare india | Adrenal Gland Disorders Treatment in India | Benign Urethral Lesions Treatment in India | Bladder Diverticulum Treatment in India | Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (BPH) Treatment in India | Bladder Prolapse (Cystocele) Treatment in India | Buried Penis Treatment in India | Ectopic Kidneys Treatment in India | Extrinsic Obstruction of the Ureter Treatment in India | Fistula Treatment in India | Hematuria Treatment in India | Hydroceles and Inguinal Hernias Treatment in India | Interstitial Cystitis Treatment in India | Prostatitis Treatment in India | Peyronie's Disease Treatment in India | Renal Fusion (Horseshoe Kidney) Treatment in India | Spermatoceles Treatment in India | Urine Incontinence Treatment in India | Urinary Tract Infection Treatment in India | Ureterocele Treatment in India | Ureteropelvic Junction Obstruction Treatment in India | Urologic Pelvic Pain Syndrome Treatment in India | Urethral Stricture Disease Treatment in India | Varicoceles Treatment in India | Prostate Cancer Treatment in India | Bladder Cancer Treatment in India | Cervical Cancer (Cervix) Treatment in India | Ovarian Cancer Treatment in India | Ureter Cancer (Renal Pelvis) Treatment in India | Uterine Cancer Treatment in India | Vulvar cancer Treatment in India | Kidney Cancer Treatment in India | Penile Cancer Treatment in India | Testicular Cancer Treatment in India | Urethral Cancer Treatment in India | Ovarian Germ Cell Tumour Treatment in India | Urinary Tract Infection Treatment in India | Urethral Stricture Treatment in India | Posterior Urethral Valve (PUV) Treatment in India | Urethritis Treatment in India | Urethral Syndrome Treatment in India | Urinary Tract Obstruction Treatment in India | Urethral Trauma Treatment in India | Urethral Caruncle Treatment in India | Gall Stone Treatment in India | Neurogenic Bladder Treatment in India | Bladder Exstrophy Treatment in India | Enuresis (Bedwetting) Treatment in India | Transurethral Resection (TURP) | Ureterocele Treatment in India | Stress Incontinence Treatment in India | Prostate Cancer Treatment in India | Robotic Prostatectomy Treatment in India | HIFU Treatment in India | Artificial Sphincter Surgery Treatment in India | Brachytherapy Treatment in India | Bilateral Salpingo - Oophorectomy Treatment in India | Kidney Transplant Surgery Treatment in India | Nephrectomy Treatment in India | ESWL Treatment in India | Endopyelotomy Surgery Treatment in India | Endometrial Carcinoma Surgery Treatment in India | Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy (PCNL) Treatment in India | Lithotripsy Treatment in India | Urethroplasty Surgery Treatment in India | Laparoscopic Pyeloplasty Treatment in India | Orchiectomy Treatment in India | Penile Implant Surgery Treatment in India | Orchiopexy Treatment in India | Phalloplasty Treatment in India | Radical Nephrectomy Treatment in India | Transurethral Resection of Prostate (TURP) Treatment in India | Laparoscopic Radical Prostatectomy Treatment in India | Radical Prostatectomy Treatment in India | Green Light PVP Treatment in India | Holmium Laser Surgery Treatment in India | Internal Urethrotomy Treatment in India | Uterine Fibroid Embolization (UFE) Treatment in India | Tubal Recanalisation Surgery Treatment in India | Tubal Ligation Reversal Surgery Treatment in India | Total Cystectomy Treatment in India | Priapism Treatment in India | Laparoscopic Surgery for Ovarian Cyst Treatment in India | Laparoscopic Myomectomy Treatment in India | Inguinal Hernia Surgery Treatment in India | Umbilical Hernia Surgery Treatment in India | Hiatus Hernia Surgery Treatment in India | Anal Fistula Surgery Treatment in India | Hysterectomy Surgery Treatment in India | Penectomy Treatment in India | Pro Lapse Bladder Surgery Treatment in India | Pelvic Lymph Node Dissection Treatment in India | Disorders of Sex Development (DSD) Treatment in India | Benign Urethral Lesions in Children - Boys Treatment in India | Benign Urethral Lesions in Children - Girls Treatment in India | Bladder Exstrophy Treatment in India | Bladder Fistula Treatment in India | Ectopic Kidneys Treatment in India | Ectopic Ureter Treatment in India | Epispadias Treatment in India | Hydroceles and Inguinal Hernias Treatment in India | Hydronephrosis Treatment in India | Hypospadias/Failed Hypospadias Treatment in India | Multicystic kidney Treatment in India | Neurogenic Bladder Treatment in India | Penile Trauma Treatment in India | Posterior urethral valve Treatment in India | Renal Fusion (Horseshoe Kidney) Treatment in India | Undescended Testis Treatment in India | Ureterocele Treatment in India | Ureteropelvic Junction Obstruction Treatment in India | Varicoceles Treatment in India | Vesicoureteral Reflux Treatment in India | Bladder Prolapse (Cystocele) Treatment in India | Fibroids Uterus Treatment in India | Fecal Incontinence Treatment in India | Gynecologic Tumor Markers Treatment in India | Hematuria Treatment in India | Interstitial Cystitis Treatment in India | Incontinence of urine Treatment in India | Minimally Invasive Management of Urinary Incontinence Treatment in India | Overactive Bladder Treatment in India | Ovarian Cyst Treatment in India | Prolapse of pelvic organs Treatment in India | Trans Vaginal Tape (TVT) Treatment in India | Urethral Diverticulum Treatment in India | Vaginal Cancer Treatment in India | Uterine Prolapse Treatment in India | Voiding Dysfunction Treatment in India | Vaginitis Treatment in India | Vesicovaginal Fistula Treatment in India | Kidney Stone Treatment in India | Bladder Stone Treatment in India | Ureteral Stones Treatment in India


Mobile Links

Erectile Dysfunction ED Treatment in India | Diabetes cause Impotence Treatment India | Penile Prosthesis in India | Penile Implant Surgery Treatment in India | Prostate Cancer Impotence Treatment in India | Penile Implant International Patient Experience | Medical Tourism in India | Phalloplasty Surgery in India | Cosmetic Penile Surgery in India | Penile Implant candidate | Types of Penile Implants | Top Urologist Surgeons in India | Causes of Impotence and Treatment in India | Lithotripsy Surgery in India | Peyronie Disease Treatment in India | Priapism Treatment in India | Shockwave Therapy for Erectile Dysfunction in India | ED1000 Treatment in India | Urethroplasty Surgery in India | Urethral Stricture Surgery in India | Cystoscopy Surgery in India | Inguinal Hernia Surgery in India | Urologic Pelvic Pain Syndrome Surgery in India | FAQ About Penile Implant Surgery in India | Urinary Incontinence Treatment India | TUR-Bladder Tumour Surgery in India | Internal Urethrotomy Surgery in India | Anastomotic Urethroplasty Technique India | Tissue Transfer Urethroplasty Surgery in India | Buccal Mucosal Graft Urethroplasty India | Penile Urethroplasty using Skin Flap India | Johansen's Urethroplasty India | Radical Nephrectomy Surgery India | Nephrostomy Surgery India | Endopyelotomy Surgery India | Ureteroscopy for Kidney Stones India | Transurethral Resection of Prostate (TURP) India | Total Cystectomy Surgery India | Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy India | Laparoscopic Pyeloplasty Surgery India | Orchiectomy Surgery India | Orchiopexy Surgery India | Radical Prostatectomy Surgery in India | Vesicovaginal Fistula Surgery in India | Trans Vaginal Tape India | Premature Ejaculation Treatment in India | Robotic Prostatectomy Surgery in India | Artificial Urinary Sphincter Surgery in India | Fibroid Removal Myomectomy Surgery in India | Penectomy Surgery India | ASK THE DOCTOR | Prostate Cancer - Overview, causes, symptoms and treatment in India